This guy would own a couple dozen albums and at least as many mixtapes, I reckon. So he's got a reasonable amount to choose from.

Tainted Love is a good shout. Total Eclipse of the Heart probably too focused on romance and feminine (we're talking Patrick Merrick from Antonia Forest's books, for the one or two people that will find the
prospect as funny as I just did!)

I've never heard of Love Stinks nor the J.Geils Band, so I suspect they wouldn't have made it here at all. (yup, never charted outside NA and Australia)